Operation Management

Operation Management

Student Name:

Student Id:

Introduction

This report analyses how operations and value creation are influenced by human resource management systems and information systems in Volkswagen, Accenture, and HSBC. It displays how Volkswagen works in workforce management and training for effective response to the challenging market of today’s automotive industry, how Accenture leverages HRM and IS to improve service delivery in the consulting industry as well as the case of HSBC which has illustrates how the theoretical concepts of HRM and IS can be applied to the banking industry for increased efficiency in operations, compliance and customer services. Through such dynamics, the report highlights the vital importance of integrated management practice in sales, products, and overall operations of these diverse organizations.

Task 1

Section 1: Operations and Core Support Functions

Section 1(a): Interrelationships between Operations, HR, and Information Systems

Operations management is crucial in ensuring the right functions in an organization are carried out effectively, and promptly because one thing is to plan, and another to effectively execute those plans. The following is a breakdown of how operations cut across with HRM and IS in Volkswagen, Accenture, and HSBC.

Volkswagen: Operations and HR/IS

This paper aims to analyze the relationship between operation and human resource management to sustain the production rate at the world’s leading automobile company, Volkswagen. This is a remarkable piece of work by HR because it involves proactively looking for highly skilled workers and developing training to match advances in manufacturing technologies surrounding assembly lines. Employee selection, training, and retention affect Volkswagen's performance since timely and proper staffing is crucial to prevent losses due to compliance issues (Piwowar-Sulej, K., 2021).

The relationship between operations and IS at Volkswagen is also basic, especially with the advancement in automation technology in car manufacturing. In producing facilities, the IS systems enhance operational effectiveness by providing real-time data on production processes like inventory and logistics which makes it possible to predict and do maintenance and improve the supply value chain. Industry 4.0 solutions also help Volkswagen to integrate automation of operations and improvement of information exchange between machines and operators.

Accenture: Operations and HR/IS

At Accenture, a service-based consulting company, operation relies on HR to provide manpower for a particular project through well-skilled human resources. Talent management by human resources enables the organization to hire the right consultants and train and deploy them properly. It also ensures that the company directs adequate resources towards its projects, hence achieving various goals to the needed level.

Information Systems play a crucial role at Accenture specifically in the efficiency of service delivery mechanisms including cloud platforms, project management tools, and communication technology. IS makes client conversations concise and optimized, project processes clear and coherent, and ensures that service delivery is consistent across teams all over the world helping Accenture deliver on its digital transformation platform (Piwowar-Sulej, K., 2021).

HSBC: Operations and HR/IS

HSBC is one of the largest international banks the role of HR in managing organizational performance includes providing skills necessary for different operations including banking, managing risks, and conforming to the regulatory requirements. Another important area that HR strongly supports is innovation and, in particular, leadership development within the operations function which seems to be so important for the changes in the financial sector.

IS is very vital to HSBC banking, such as digital banking, real-time transactions, customer service, and many others. IS systems help HSBC to store and protect the data, provide the means for adequate functioning of the banking industry, and cut back on unnecessary expenditures that enhance the effectiveness of the banking system on an international level.

Section 1(b): Impact of Operations and Processes on Other Functions at Volkswagen

In analyzing the influence on core functions like Sales and Marketing and Product Development it is important to understand inputs and outputs of operations. The different aspects enable companies to optimize utilization of their assets and resources as well as processes to obtain outcomes commensurate with companies' strategic outcomes. Next, it analyzes the effect of inputs and outputs of operations at Volkswagen on these two critical functions (Kamble, et. al., 2023).

Sales and Marketing

Operations functions are linked to Volkswagen’s Sales and Marketing divisions. The functionality directly affects the service level, and hence the availability and timing of products into the market that is important in marketing strategies. Sometimes in production, marketing strategies are coordinated with production timetables so as to guarantee that promotions are realistic. High production efficiency implies the timely delivery of products to the market, thus increasing the appropriateness of sales plans (Zhang, and Chen., 2024).

Processes

Inputs: Market research data, production capabilities, customer feedback.

Outputs: Sales figures, marketing analytics, promotional materials.

The operations team avails information by forecasting the demand level, which the marketing team utilizes in coming up with the right strategies. Quality is obtained when a company produces goods that are always of good quality hence improving the image of the firm’s products and their sale in the market.

Product/Service Development

There is a strong link between the operations team and the Product/Service Development team at Volkswagen and they are critical to the creation of innovations as well as quality changes (Zhang, and Chen., 2024). Skills and constraints of production are well illuminated by operations, the information guides the choices of practicable new models.

Processes

Inputs: Customer needs assessments, technological advancements, and material specifications.

Outputs: Prototypes, new vehicle models, product specifications.

With regards to operations the PD process starts with data on the existing model; improving or modifying it or creating another that can be produced. The operations feedback helps the development team to design products that are most suitable for manufacturing as well as those that are cheap to make.

The operations integration with Human Resource Management and Information Systems in Volkswagen impacts the efficiency and effectiveness of sales and marketing, and product and service delivery, hence business gains.

Input	Processes	Outputs
Human Resources	Workforce	Finished Products/ Services
Technology	Assembly/ Production	Reports
Market Data	Data Analysis & Reporting	Customer Feedback
Materials	Quality Control	Waste/ Errors
Capital/ Financial Resources	Communication & Collaboration

Impact Analysis

The Volkswagen example uses operations to show how alignment in inputs and outputs, as well as the interplay between operations and key functions like Sales and Marketing and Product Development, is critical. Volkswagen achieves this by using operational efficiency to afford robust marketing campaigns and product designs that consistently meet customer expectations and maintain it in the competitive space. For long-term success, any inefficiencies in these processes have to be addressed.

Section 2 Operations Management and Sustainability

Section 2 (a): Application of the Four Vs Model

Volume, Variety, Variation, and Visibility model stands for Four Vs and assists in identifying operations-related issues of companies. The juxtaposition of this model to Volkswagen, Accenture, and HSBC reveals the marked distinctions between the three companies (Tsougkou, et. al., 2024).

Volkswagen

• Volume: Volkswagen has a mass production system and manufactures millions of vehicles every year. This high volume, in turn, allows for better utilization of the economies of scale but puts pressure on the organization in terms of achieving efficiency levels which would call for standardized and/or even automated processes.

• Variety: Although Volkswagen has different series of cars such as sedans, SUVs, and electric cars; Volkswagen has a few models for each category because it follows the tactic of standardization. Modular manufacturing facilitates the work of the management of the impact arising from the existence of the various models (Bergström, and Edstrand., 2021).

• Variation in Demand: The demand for vehicles varies as influenced by market factors and other trends like the electric vehicle market. The above changes are factors Volkswagen has to consider when making changes in production schedules (Zhang, and Chen., 2024).

• Visibility: Some degree of openness is visible to customers; customers can monitor customized orders, but most processes are obscure. However sustainable trends are making businesses more and more disclose their information about emissions and sourcing.

Accenture

• Volume: For this reason, Accenture has less volume compared to the manufacturing industry, which as a professional service provider, delivers very specialized consulting services in response to the needs of specific clients.

• Variety: It is operating in a high variety context providing a full-service offering across strategy, technology consulting, and covering industries. Operations have to be flexible enough to accommodate the variation in clients' needs (Bergström, and Edstrand., 2021).

• Variation in Demand: Consulting demand is therefore highly responsive to economic changes. Currently, Accenture has constantly adjustable staffing and organizational capacities to handle fluctuations in workload.

• Visibility: The level of openness is very good since the consultant and the client engage in constant interactions throughout the projects.

HSBC

• Volume: HSBC has a huge number of transactions daily and therefore requires a strong system to process millions of financial transactions (Bergström, and Edstrand., 2021).

• Variety: HSBC provides a rather limited array of offerings, including retail banking and investment services, and thereby utilizes standardization to achieve uniformity between countries.

• Variation in Demand: It is volatile with the business cycles which means loan or investment services to customers. All of these require operational changes in HSBC (Xuewen, and Loang., 2024).

• Visibility: This is so since most banking operations are mission-critical and out of sight of the customer unless the operations are done directly over the counter.

Critical Analysis of the Four Vs Model

Mass production is consistent with the manufacturing sector’s standardization where Volkswagen operates at high volume and low variety while on the other end of the spectrum is low volume, high variety of services offered by Accenture. HSBC simultaneously lies in a high activity and moderate differentiation of transactions (Supratikta, Hasanah, and Dharmaesta., 2024). The Nine C’s model contains some important insights for operation management issues but fails to consider such contextual factors as technology and sustainability, which are crucial for operations management more and more at present.

Section 2 (b): Measuring Sustainable Business Operations

Indeed, Volkswagen, as well as HSBC, apply sustainable measurement at both the societal, strategic, and operational tiers even though the processes have unique characteristics of the car industry and banking sector respectively.

Volkswagen

• Societal Level: Sustainability or social responsibility actions at Volkswagen are measured by the company with the help of such measures as decreasing the emission of CO2 and the shift to electric cars. Its targets are related to the objectives of the Paris Climate Agreement and they envision carbon neutrality by 2050. Others include ethical sourcing, and embracing the community (Akhmatova, et. al., 2022).

• Strategic Level: Today, the company’s strategy centers on increasing electric car manufacturing ratios. The company’s success is defined by achieving market share of EVs, productivity improvements that reduce costs, and strategic collaborations in battery technologies. It is also committed to sustainable planning as part of its strategic development.

• Operational Level: At the second level of VOC, at the operational level, Volkswagen keeps track of the production rate, energy utilization, and waste management. The following performance indicators are used; average number of units manufactured in a given hour and kilowatt hour per vehicle (Akhmatova, et. al., 2022).

HSBC

• Societal Level: These, and HSBC, are committed to sustainable finance, and it reports on its efforts to reach the goal of financing $1 trillion in green projects by 2030. Thus, the bank guarantees financial accessibility and minimizes its pollution of the natural environment as its contribution to society.

• Strategic Level: HSBC incorporates Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) standards into its propositions and tracks performance through green bonds and through tackling large exposure to environmentally unfriendly sectors (Omare, A.N., 2023). The ESG performance indicators are assessed by using the annual reports and scorecards.

• Operational Level: HSBC defines efficiency with the number of transactions processed, the energy consumed, and the amount of paper used in the organization's activities. Measures like the number of transactions affected accurately, and the percentage of time that the system is available denoting sustainability at the bank (Omare, A.N., 2023).

Comparison of Sustainability Measures

Sustainability for Volkswagen has to do with the reduced environmental footprint, especially through electric cars as well as sourcing responsibly. As for the latter, sustainable finance is important and HSBC prioritizes it; thereby, its offerings meet society's needs such as financing renewable energy (Kumar, et. al., 2022). While both organizations use metrics to account for the energy consumed and for resources used, what we have for Volkswagen is the manufacturing efficiency; for HSBC it is the positive social contribution made by balanced and responsible sourcing and investing.

Section 3: Optimizing Performance through Total Quality Management and LEAN/KAIZEN

Section 3 (a): Applying TQM and LEAN/KAIZEN to Volkswagen’s Performance

Total Quality Management (TQM)

TQM is an organizational management model that emphasizes the ongoing improvement of the quality and comprehensiveness of the organization (Hongal, and Kinange., 2020). At Volkswagen, TQM can optimize performance through several key areas:

• Customer-Centric Quality: TQM allows Volkswagen to sustain an overall high quality across its entire product development and manufacturing cycles. If Volkswagen continually gathers and incorporates customer feedback in its production, the company will be able to deliver vehicles that conform to the customers’ expectations essential for success within the highly competitive automobile market.

• Process Improvement: It also entails constant enhancement since the main idea of the implementation is to enhance the process, which will assist Volkswagen in packaging and production services (Hongal, and Kinange., 2020). Hence use of quality control tools such as Six Sigma can assist Volkswagen to minimize vehicle defects that cause recalls resulting in customer satisfaction.

• Employee Involvement: TQM fosters organizational development for employee participation in the identification of issues that affect quality. In VW, productivity can be improved and a positive work culture can be developed if the management encourages workers, engineers, and managers to work as a team (Adeniran, et. al., 2024).

LEAN/KAIZEN
Lean and Kaizen are the tools used in business where the central idea is to reduce losses or waste. LEAN provides the elimination of non-value-added activities and constant improvement, whereas KAIZEN focuses only on continuous improvement (Tsougkou, et. al., 2024). Volkswagen can apply LEAN/KAIZEN in several ways:

• Waste Reduction: Part of Volkswagen's business case, LEAN can be applied to reduce cost waste in production by avoiding overproduction, decreasing inventories, and enhancing the flow. These moves cut costs of production and therefore support Volkswagen’s sustainability goals because they minimize the use of resources.

• Continuous Improvement (KAIZEN): The KAIZEN outlook perpetuates an ongoing form of change in Volkswagen’s workforce. This continuous improvement can also help to sustain very high levels of efficiency in production and the workers may be directed to developing the qualities of products.

• Efficiency Gains: LEAN and KAIZEN can be used to enhance the production cycle time of Volkswagen because it will cut down time on the cycles it uses, and at the same time make it possible for Honda to adjust its production for new and current products such as electric vehicles (Zhou, et. al., 2021).

Section 3 (b): Comparing the Benefits and Limitations of TQM and LEAN/KAIZEN at Volkswagen

Benefits of TQM

• Holistic Quality Focus: TQM pays a significant focus to customers and processes, to guarantee that the quality of the product is not compromised by failures but rather all these issues are addressed as they occur.

• Employee Engagement: The benefit of applying the TQM is that it provides higher employee involvement, as well as higher levels of innovation within the organization.

• Reputation and Compliance: TQM implementation for Volkswagen assists in upgrading its image of delivering quality automobiles alongside meeting standard quality standards such as ISO 9001.

Limitations of TQM

• Implementation Complexity: The application of TQM across corporate giants like Volkswagen entails some major changes in systems; this and a host of other training programs would cost a great deal of money and time.

• Measurement Challenges: It can be therefore problematical on occasions to compare some aspects of improvement activities such as customer satisfaction about more easily measurable parameters such as defect rates about improvements brought about by a program such as TQM.

Benefits of LEAN/KAIZEN

• Cost Savings: LEAN aims to add value and eliminate non-value-added activities thus enhancing the resource productivity base of an organization hence reducing costs associated with overproduction, idle inventory, and wastage of resources (Diez-Cañamero, et. al., 2020).

• Agility and Flexibility: Through the adoption of LEAN, Volkswagen can work faster than the increased speed of consumers’ changes, especially in areas such as electric vehicles.

• Employee Empowerment: KAIZEN engages workers to embrace small steps in their working process hence improving morale and productivity.

Limitations of LEAN/KAIZEN

• Short-Term Focus: Compared to KAIZEN, more value-added improvements are likely to take place gradually, which can be slow for dramatic improvement measures vital for competitiveness in a changing and emergent industry.

• Sustainability Challenges: The libido for efficiency inherent in LEAN may harm sustainable long-term value by not having enough inventory on hand to support the development of meanwhile green technologies.

Comparison of TQM and LEAN/KAIZEN

Thus, TQM and LEAN/KAIZEN are a combination of demands that bring value to improve the performance of Volkswagen but with differences in emphases. TQM over a wider view, integrating quality in each method and focusing on customer satisfaction is useful to long-term strategic quality programs. On the other hand, LEAN/KAIZEN is more efficiency-oriented with efficiency aiming to remove all wastes and achieve efficient flows, and despite of bureaucratic and cyclic character, it brings more immediate operational advantages in Volkswagen production where high production volumes exist (Zhou, et. al., 2021).

These two models give active participation of the employees but in different ways. On the other hand, while LEAN/KAIZEN is specific to incremental improvements from the bottom up, the goal of TQM is to develop change throughout the whole organization.

Thus, together with TQM and LEAN/KAIZEN, Volkswagen can achieve simultaneous improvement in all aspects of its operation, while maintaining the pursued program’s focus on the quality of products and satisfaction of customers. While TQM improves on sustainable quality improvements, LEAN/KAIZEN provides short-term improvements in the efficiency of an organization. To be effective, these strategies have to be incorporated into Volkswagen and their drawbacks must be explained to maintain high performance and long-term success.

Section 4: Sales & Operations Planning and Its Impact on Customer Satisfaction and Supply Chain Relationships

Section 4 (a): Implementing Sales & Operations Planning to Meet Customer Expectations

Volkswagen: S&OP and Meeting Customer Expectations

In Volkswagen, it is essential to synchronize sales expectations with production to fit the market requirements. Implementing Sales & Operations Planning (S&OP) supports this through:

• Improved Demand Forecasting: S&OP gives Volkswagen the ability to match sales and production so that the correct car models are manufactured to fulfill demand. For instance, given the increasing demand for electric vehicles (EVs), S&OP enables companies to shift their production patterns from excessive production of regular models during times when they are starting to produce EVs (Kamble, et. al., 2023).

• Enhanced Inventory Management: S&OP reduces inventory exposure so that technicians do not run out of critical items nor have to wait too long for them. This means that Volkswagen can better meet supply and demand needs, ramp up delivery, and boost customer satisfaction.

• Cross-functional Collaboration: S&OP positively promotes cooperation between sales and operations, product development where customer feedback is integrated into future production elements like in-car technology or any environmentally-conscious modifications retaining Volkswagen as a fitting competitor in the market (Kamble, et. al., 2023).

HSBC: S&OP and Meeting Customer Expectations

In a service-oriented company like HSBC, S&OP helps balance services with operational capacity:

• Improved Resource Allocation: With the help of S&OP HSBC is able to plan how better to allocate resources such as IT infrastructure to meet the needs of the increasing demand for digital banking services which can be enabled while keeping a good quality of delivery.

• Service Customization: Through the application of the S&OP, HSBC can tailor its products in line with the buying trends of its clients; the development of sustainable finance products and services will enhance the HSBC brand’s popularity among environmentally conscious users (Kamble, et. al., 2023).

• Operational Efficiency: Aligning the services, IT, and product development teams, S&OP reduces delay to ensure optimum service delivery at HSBC hence improving customer experience.

Section 4 (b): Impact of S&OP on Supply Chain Management

Volkswagen: Impact of S&OP on Supply Chain Relationships

Volkswagen company has several suppliers that operate in various countries throughout the world making their supply chain management a critical operation requiring integration and risk analysis. S&OP improves its supply chain in the following ways:

• Stronger Supplier Coordination: S&OP assists Volkswagen in giving suppliers more accurate demand signals and subsequently minimizes delivery timetables and product variability. This increases the flexibility of supply and demand to meet Volkswagen’s requirements to provide less lead time and increase the overall effectiveness of supply chain management (Bergström, and Edstrand., 2021).

• Enhanced Risk Management: Using S&OP, Volkswagen can identify supply chain risks at an early stage for instance in such conditions as global ones such as the lack of semiconductors. Changing or making adjustments in production is made easier, or changing suppliers is not so disruptive.

• Sustainability in Supply Chain: S&OP contributes to Volkswagen’s sustainability by engaging suppliers and working together to embed its climate objectives into the supply chain so that customers receive climate-conscious automobiles (Supratikta, Hasanah, and Dharmaesta., 2024).

HSBC: Impact of S&OP on Supply Chain Relationships

In the case of HSBC, supply chain relations refer to relations with supplies in IT and related fintech companies. S&OP helps in the following ways:

• Improved Service Level Agreements (SLAs): Demand-resource fit enables better updating of Service Level Agreements to meet the needs of IT and fintech providers. It allows providers to be ready to handle additional services required, for instance, Transaction volume during bust hours.

• Technology Innovation: S&OP provides HSBC with a strong base for better cooperation with fintech firms, as well as designing new banking products according to the customer needs in order to remain technologically ahead (Zhou, et. al., 2021).

• Cost Efficiency and Compliance: When applying an S&OP process to compliance, the company can guarantee that its partners, like data centers, comply with the regulations at an optimal cost to HSBC and with an uncompromised service level.

Adopting Sales & Operations Planning (S&OP) has a lot of potential for Volkswagen and HSBC to meet customer needs and enhance supply chain partners’ bonds. For Volkswagen, S&OP reconciles supply with demand and also improves supplier relationships and risk management. In the case of HSBC, S&OP also helps in integrating services to meet customer needs and building more robust fintech and IT relationships. However, the field of S&OP is different at each company – Volkswagen is focused on various physical supply chains, while HSBC is focused on the relations based on services and technology (Kumar, et. al., 2022).

Conclusion

In the end, the planning and implementation of business operations, human resources, and information systems for organizations such as Volkswagen, Accenture, and HSBC are intertwined which underlines the importance of the concept of collaboration for operations. Efficient manufacturing techniques enriched Volkswagen's Sales & Marketing as well as Product Development divisions utilizing strategic production to turn around suitable production to fit the market. The application of the four Vs model also helps the respective organizations in understanding the major operation challenges which are quite significant to comprehend the strategies on which the organizations are working. Furthermore, they observed that the practice of Total Quality Management and LEAN/KAIZEN approaches can enhance performance by improving not only quality but also enhancing efficiency. Finally, such approaches promote acquires and viability to cope with competitive and unpredictable situations and contexts.

Reference

Adeniran, I.A., Abhulimen, A.O., Obiki-Osafiele, A.N., Osundare, O.S., Agu, E.E. and Efunniyi, C.P., 2024. Strategic risk management in financial institutions: Ensuring robust regulatory compliance. Finance & Accounting Research Journal, 6(8), pp.1582-1596.https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Angela-Abhulimen/publication/383860845_Strategic_risk_management_in_financial_institutions_Ensuring_robust_regulatory_compliance/links/66ddab972390e50b2c769a9a/Strategic-risk-management-in-financial-institutions-Ensuring-robust-regulatory-compliance.pdf

Akhmatova, M.S., Deniskina, A., Akhmatova, D.M. and Prykina, L., 2022. Integrating quality management systems (TQM) in the digital age of intelligent transportation systems industry 4.0. Transportation research procedia, 63, pp.1512-1520.https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2352146522004185/pdf?md5=186aa5d561ece25c4d13094091a984fd&pid=1-s2.0-S2352146522004185-main.pdf

Aldoseri, A., Al-Khalifa, K. and Hamouda, A., 2023. A roadmap for integrating automation with process optimization for AI-powered digital transformation.https://www.preprints.org/manuscript/202310.1055/download/final_file

Bergström, B. and Edstrand, H., 2021. Managing Sustainability in Strategic Decision-Making, Life cycle thinking for sustainable innovation,-A case study at Volvo Cars.https://odr.chalmers.se/bitstream/20.500.12380/302849/1/E2021_025.pdf

Diez-Cañamero, B., Bishara, T., Otegi-Olaso, J.R., Minguez, R. and Fernández, J.M., 2020. Measurement of corporate social responsibility: A review of corporate sustainability indexes, rankings and ratings. Sustainability, 12(5), p.2153.https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/12/5/2153/pdf

Hongal, P. and Kinange, U., 2020. A study on talent management and its impact on organization performance-an empirical review. International Journal of Engineering and Management Research, 10.https://www.academia.edu/download/104467549/IJEMR2020100112.pdf

Kamble, S.S., Gunasekaran, A., Subramanian, N., Ghadge, A., Belhadi, A. and Venkatesh, M., 2023. Blockchain technology’s impact on supply chain integration and sustainable supply chain performance: Evidence from the automotive industry. Annals of Operations Research, 327(1), pp.575-600.https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/s10479-021-04129-6.pdf

Kumar, N., Hasan, S.S., Srivastava, K., Akhtar, R., Yadav, R.K. and Choubey, V.K., 2022. Lean manufacturing techniques and its implementation: A review. Materials Today: Proceedings, 64, pp.1188-1192.https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Naveen-Kumar-203/publication/359755818_Lean_manufacturing_techniques_and_its_implementation_A_review/links/6356640112cbac6a3eef5c86/Lean-manufacturing-techniques-and-its-implementation-A-review.pdf

Omare, A.N., 2023. Effect Of Sustainability Finance Practices On Organizational Performance Of Commercial Banks In Kenya (Doctoral dissertation, Kca University).https://repository.kcau.ac.ke/bitstream/handle/123456789/1530/Omare-Effect%20Of%20Sustainability%20Finance%20Practices%20On%20Organizational%20Performance%20Of%20Commercial%20Banks%20In%20Kenya.pdf?sequence=1

Piwowar-Sulej, K., 2021. Human resources development as an element of sustainable HRM–with the focus on production engineers. Journal of cleaner production, 278, p.124008.https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0959652620340531

Supratikta, H., Hasanah, T. and Dharmaesta, L.A., 2024. UTILIZATION OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY IN FINANCIAL DECISION-MAKING: ANALYSIS ON MANAGEMENT INFORMATION SYSTEMS. Multidisciplinary Indonesian Center Journal (MICJO), 1(3), pp.1223-1229.https://e-jurnal.jurnalcenter.com/index.php/micjo/article/download/145/151

Tsougkou, E., Sykora, M., Elayan, S., Ifie, K. and Oliveira, J.S., 2024. EXPRESS: Peace Brand Activism: Global Brand Responses to the War in Ukraine. Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, p.07439156241289079.https://repository.lboro.ac.uk/articles/journal_contribution/EXPRESS_Peace_Brand_Activism_global_brand_responses_to_the_war_in_Ukraine/27221043/1/files/49767126.pdf

Xuewen, L. and Loang, O.K., 2024. THE IMPACT OF ORGANISATIONAL ON HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT IN SERVICE INDUSTRIES. International Journal of Accounting, 9(53), pp.64-71.https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Ooi-Kok-Loang/publication/379824373_The_impact_of_organisational_on_Human_Resource_Management_in_service_industries/links/661cff0866ba7e2359da8a95/The-impact-of-organisational-on-Human-Resource-Management-in-service-industries.pdf

Zhang, J. and Chen, Z., 2024. Exploring human resource management digital transformation in the digital age. Journal of the Knowledge Economy, 15(1), pp.1482-1498.https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/s13132-023-01214-y.pdf

Zhou, F., Chen, T., Hai, P., Ma, P. and Pratap, S., 2021. Strategic Quality Improvement Management Practice for Domestic Automobile Industry from the Crucial Outsourcing Part Perspective. Engineering Letters, 29(1).https://www.engineeringletters.com/issues_v29/issue_1/EL_29_1_30.pdf