Logo of Zappos.com
Zappos is a US based shoe and clothing company with headquarters in Las Vegas. The company does its business through online. The company started 15 year ago in 1999 by Nick Swinmurn as an online shoe company, but slowly expanded its business to clothing as well. The company was bought by Amazon in the year 2009. The growth rate of Zappos had been very fast and their main motive to serve their customers to the best of their capability made them bring lot of changes to their organization structure. The company was the first to realize the importance of online shopping. The main vision of the company is to be the best online store to provide the best service to the customers. The company thinks that the only disadvantage of online service is the time taken to complete the transaction which is overcome by the quick door to door delivery by Zappos.com. This report will focus on the organizational structure and culture at Zappos and how it changed with passage of time to bring flexibility in their approach to meet ever changing customer request. The report will also discuss the leadership styles followed in Zappos and how various organization and behaviour theories are implemented by the HR of Zappos into their practice within the organization. The report will also focus on the unique division of company into what they call circles and how it is helpful for the company to deliver high level of service.
Hierarchical structure is one where there are many layers in an organization. The people at one layer are controlled by the people present at immediate higher level while they control the people present at immediate lower level. Thus, hierarchical structure is considered to be an organized structure and is used by most of the companies as it used to initiate smooth functioning of the company. Some of the advantages Zappos would have faced if it would have continued with the classical hierarchical structure are:
However, some of the disadvantage Zappos would have to face if it would have continued with hierarchical structure are:
Flatter organizations means when there are comparatively less number or no number of layers in an organization i.e. everyone is considered equal. Though, most of the flatter organizations still have two three layers of hierarchy, Zappos has introduced a new concept of no bosses and titles which is known as Holacracy (Groth, 2013). Holacracy is a new concept of organizational behaviour which considers each employee at same level. A company following holacracy is performance driven company with no space for weak or lazy. Communication is best in flat organizations as people feel free to talk with anyone, which builds trust and healthy relationship among employees. People are given responsibility to participate and give their suggestions related to company’s decision, hence people feel a sense of belongingness and responsibility. The main feature of adopting Holacracy is change. Holacracy promotes innovation, new ideas and flexible approach to tackle customer’s ever changing requests and high competition. However, it is important that Zappos should understand that this type of organizational structure may be difficult to manage when the size of the company increases. Zappos with a small population of 1500 can make full use of Holacracy to make sure efficient and quick service to its customers, however, with increasing size of the company, Zappos will have to introduce certain levels to have better control over the functioning of the company.
b) Explain how the new organisational structure and culture may impact on both employee and organisational performance.
The core values of Zappos are (Dager, 2011):
One of the biggest difference between Zappos and Amazon’s leadership style is that in Amazon, the leaders keep things secret from not only public but also from its employees. On the other hand, at Zappos the key is transparency. Being an employee driven company, Zappos, the company is open to all about its functioning and decisions and even uses social networking sites like Twitter to disclose their decisions (Pentina, 2012). Amazon, on the other hand, is very private which reflects on its service, as the company is highly successful on the website, however, when dealing with customers on phone, the company fails on many occasions. Tony Hsieh, the CEO of Zappos, was even open to the employees during the collaboration with Amazon and was greatly supported by the employees at Zappos. Thus, it can be seen that the company holds a democratic style of leadership which supports equal participation of employees in making important decisions for the company (Denning, 2012).
Amazon, on the other hand, holds a relatively hierarchical structure, mostly because of the vast population of the company. The company does not involve employees and follow autocratic type of leadership style where the decision making is done by the senior and expert managers sitting at the top of the hierarchy.
No titles: Zappos new organizational behaviour, Holacracy means that there will be no manager, no titles within the company which means that there will be no leader. This kind of structure is also known as super flat organizational structure. The company who is driven by change believes that any kind of control by higher authority is a hindrance in their approach towards quick and efficient decision making to tackle the external changes (Dager, 2014). However, the distinction will be on the basis of roles and activities assigned to person. Old and experiences people will have more roles to execute compared to new employees. Tony Hsieh believes that there should not be any hiding of employees inside titles and still not perform. The employees will be rewarded only on the basis of performance and not on time spent with the organization. The company took the step to adopt Holacracy structure to maintain radical transparency. The company will still have people who will be known as Lead-links, who will assign different roles to different employees but will not supervise them or assist them in decision making. The power to take decisions will be in the hands of employees and teams or circles with which they are associated.
Figure 2: Difference between Traditional Structure and Holacracy model
However, it is important to understand that the new Holacracy organizational model adopted by Zappos is very new and has not been implemented by many organizations. The other company to adopt this model is Twitter which has a small population of less than 100 employees. 1500 employees is a big number to apply such model. The biggest disadvantage is that without supervision and control new employees might find it difficult to work. Research have proven that better control and proper organization results in better performance as people feel secure. Holacracy model, if not succeed, will backfire and can also result in abnormal results for the company.
According to Tony, the leadership followed at Zappos is known as freedom-centred leadership which is driven by innovation, distribution of power to everyone and encourages and support talent rather than titles and seniority.
a) Examine how Zappos leadership style may affect the motivation of their employees during the organisational re-structuring
Zappos leadership style as mentioned has been termed as freedom-centred leadership style. According to Hertzberg motivational theory, there are two type of factors. The first type of factors also known as hygiene factors are payments, hikes, bonuses, etc. whose absence demotivate employees but whose presence doesn’t play any significance role. The second factor also known as motivational factors like sharing decision-making power, giving more responsibility, recognition, etc. which motivates the employees to work hard.
It can be seen that following Hertzberg’s dual factor theory, the company changed its structure and made sure that each employee is given complete freedom in making decision for the company (Medinilla, 2012).
Some of the important features of leadership style and its impact on motivation are:
Thus, it can be seen that, during the change in organizational structure of Zappos from traditional hierarchical structure to no-title, no-manager structure, the company has done well to keep its employees motivated and the culture of the company complemented the change to bring high level performance for the company.
Click to Read all Hamilton College Assignments
As mentioned in the previous sections that the Holacracy model adopted by Zappos is highly risky and can create chaos and confusion in the functioning of the company, if things not go well for Zappos. The company consists of 1500 employees and the company is still growing. It is better that the company should have one or two level of hierarchy which can control the functioning of the employees. The company should look to have 1st level managers i.e. supervisors and general managers like the branch managers, etc. Some of the main reason for such an approach will be:
A relatively hierarchical approach will make sure that employees are well controlled and supervised while still having power to take decisions and thus it will not bring much difference in the motivational level of the employees.
With increase in the number of employees, the company should continue to increase the level of hierarchy and return to traditional approach for better functioning and keep its employees motivated.
Benefits of motivation on Zappos and its employees:
a) Explain the behaviours and dynamics of groups, including the factors that may inhibit effective group formation and teamwork
The approach followed at Zappos to form circles has the following management areas:
Some of these circles are depicted in the following diagram:
Figure 3: Circle Structure in Zappos
Some of the benefits of having dynamic groups like circle at Zappos are discussed below (Jones, 2012):
However, there are some disadvantage of having such structure:
Thus, it can be seen that Zappos is change driven company. The company is among the few organizations to adopt Holacracy business model and have been a success in the last couple of year after its implementation. However, the leadership style followed by Zappos is analysed and suggestions are given to improve and change the style with passage of time when the company will grow in number. The company’s new style of forming teams or circles based on roles and not titles is also something new and unique. The major advantage and disadvantage related to formation of circles were discussed and suggestions were given to improve it. In the last part, the impact of technology and how it helped Zappos to be the company they are today is discussed.
No Data Found